Cakes for all occasions
We make cakes for any occasion whether it's a birthday, baby shower or just because you want cake (yes, that is an occasion too). We use buttercream and fondant to make each piece of decor for your cake all by hand.
Ordering a cake with us is easy, you just have to follow these simple steps:
Step 1. Plan! Plan! Plan!
This is the most important step in the cake ordering process because all of our cakes are ALWAYS made fresh to order. Every piece of decor is handmade and takes time to create. We ask that when ordering custom cakes you give us a minimum of 2 weeks notice. This allows us to take the time and care required to create a beautiful cake for you.
Step 2. Have pictures!
We love when you bring us pictures because it's the easiest way to know what you want your cake to look like. If you don't have pictures that's okay. We will work with you to come up with a beautiful design.
Step 3. Know the details.
This includes when you need the cake, how many people you need to serve and flavors. Having all the details when you place your order allows us to quote you a price quicker.
Step 4.
Have a budget in mind.
We get it, you saw a picture on Pinterest of a beautiful cake and you just have to have it. You get the quote and it's just outside of your budget. That's okay! We work with budgets of all sizes. It is our mission is give you a beautiful cake for a price you can afford.
Step 5.
Fill out our Cake Inquiry Form or simply email us at info@sugarpiebakerywv.com. We do not take orders via phone, ONLY email. We require a record of all communication, pictures and payment information etc.
See, ordering with us is a piece of cake ;)
Most Popular Flavors
Vanilla *GF & V
Chocolate *GF & V
Red Velvet *GF
Lemon *GF & V
Raspberry
Almond *GF & V
Strawberry
Chocolate Peanut Butter *GF
Cookies and Cream
Italian Cream
German Chocolate
You are not limited to these flavors. Click here to see a full list of flavors. If you are wanting a flavor that you don't see on our list never fear, we are capable of making just about anything and we are always creating new flavors. Call the bakery and ask to speak with a baker about cake flavors.
Pricing Info
6"
3 Layers of Cake
(serves 14)
8"
3 Layers of Cake
(serves 24)
*Most popular size for custom cakes!
10"
2 Layers of Cake
(serves 24)
1/4 sheet cake
(serves 24)
1/2 sheet
(serves 54)
Full Sheet
(serves 100)
Cake Pricing
*These prices do not include custom decor. The flavors below are examples. Depending on the flavor of cake and buttercream you choose, the final price of your cake will vary.
Classic Flavors begin at $2.75 per serving
Cake Flavors: Vanilla, Almond, Funfetti, Chocolate
Buttercream: Vanilla, Chocolate, Almond, Peanut Butter
Specialty Flavors begin at $3 per serving
Cake Flavors: Red Velvet, Strawberry, Lemon, Carrot, Raspberry, Cookies & Cream
Buttercream: Vanilla, Chocolate, Almond, Peanut Butter, Cream Cheese, Lemon, Strawberry, Raspberry, Cookies and Cream, Birthday Cake
Gourmet Flavors begin at $3.25 per serving
Cake Flavors: Strawberry Champagne, Lemon Blueberry, German Chocolate, Smores, Italian Cream
Buttercream: Vanilla, Chocolate, Almond, Peanut Butter, Cream Cheese, Lemon, Strawberry, Raspberry, Cookies and Cream, Birthday Cake















