top of page

 
We LOVE cupcakes! That's why every day you'll find eight beautiful, freshly made flavors in our case every day. And because we like to keep it interesting, our available flavors change day to day and month to month! You can always count on us to have our six Signature Flavors in the case too.































Because everyone deserves to celebrate, we also offer a limited menu of Gluten, Egg, Nut and Dairy Friendly cupcakes as well as Keto and Vegan! These tasty Allergen Friendly cupcakes are only available by special order. We kindly ask for a minimum of 24 hour advance notice. The current minimum order for our Allergen Friendly cupcakes is one dozen of the same flavor.


To order, give us a call at 304-205-7753 or send an email to info@sugarpiebakerywv.com. Since we bake our cupcakes fresh every morning, we can usually accommodate orders placed as soon as the day before you need them! However, larger orders or customized flavors and decorations are harder to accommodate on a days notice. It's best to place these orders as far in advance as one-two weeks.

Before ordering, check out our cupcake flavor list to help you choose the perfect flavors for your event! Keep in mind that we don't keep all these flavors on hand daily and if you're interested in flavors we don't have available, we kindly ask that you order them by the dozen (minimum order one dozen). 


 

Red Velvet

Southern style Red Velvet cake with just a hint of cocoa that we finish with our tangy & delicious Cream Cheese Buttercream.

Cookies & Cream

We add Oreo chunks to our Chocolate cake then top it with Oreo Buttercream!

Chocolate Peanut Butter

Our super rich chocolate cake + a light and fluffy Peanut Butter Buttercream with a hint of salt that we top off with a Reese.

Wedding Cake

You can't go wrong with this iconic flavor! Sweet Almond cake and Buttercream make the perfect bite.

Funfetti

A birthday classic! Our Vanilla based cupcake is loaded with rainbow sprinkles, topped with vanilla buttercream & even more sprinkles!

Chocolate Vanilla

For those who like to keep it simple, our rich Chocolate Cake and Vanilla Buttercream is the perfect duo. We even sprinkle some rainbow sprinkles on top for extra fun.

Meet our Signature Flavors

Popular Flavors

(Not available every day)

Vanilla*

Chocolate Peanut Butter*

Red Velvet*

Chocolate Vanilla*

Wedding Cake*

Lemon*

Cookies and Cream

Strawberry*

German Chocolate

Tiramisu

Carrot

Italian Cream

Cookie Butter

(*Available in Allergen Friendly)

This is only a small list of flavors that we are able to make! For a full list of flavors, click here. We are always creating new and exciting cupcakes so feel free to call the bakery or send us an email at info@sugarpiebakerywv.com to find out what we've been creating lately!

Pricing Info

$3.25 Single Cupcake

$19.50 Per 1/2 Dozen

$39 Per Dozen

$45 Allergen Friendly Cupcakes

$42+ Per Dozen Specialty/Custom

 

bottom of page