Menu

When you come to Sugar Pie Bakery you never know what you will find in our cases. We enjoy creating new and exciting desserts however we love the classics too. Here you'll find an extensive list of the desserts we offer. Please know that you are not limited to this list. If you need a certain dessert or just a specific flavor of a dessert on our list for your special occasion give us a call or visit the bakery, we will be more than happy to speak with you!

Pies

All of our full size pies (standard 9" pie) serve 6 to 8 people and everything from the crust to the filling is made fresh to order. We ask that you call at least 48 hours in advance in place your pie orders.

Apple

Apple Berry

Peach Caramel Crumb

Mixed Berry

Blueberry

Cherry

Graham Cracker

Coconut Cream

Buttermilk

Chocolate Cream

Peanut Butter

Elvis

Pumpkin (seasonal)

Pecan

Lemon Meringue

$28 Fruit Pies/$24 Cream Pies/$18 Pumpkin Pie

Cheesecakes

Our Cheesecakes (10") will serve 8 to 10 people and like our pies, are made fresh to order. Since Cheesecakes take an entire day to bake and rest properly, we ask that you place your order at least 48 hours in advance.

New York Style with Strawberry Topping

Peanut Butter

White Chocolate Raspberry

Oreo

Pumpkin (seasonal)

Red Velvet

Lemon Blueberry

Birthday Cake

Salted Caramel

Banana Cream

Cheesecakes of any flavor $36

Macarons

Pronounced Mac-A-Ron, these french meringue cookies are a beautiful addition to any bridal shower, baby shower or wedding. Our macarons are 100% made in house and can be made in a variety of colors and flavors making them completely customizable.

Almond

Peanut Butter

Coffee

Vanilla

Raspberry

Birthday Cake

Chocolate

Lemon

Pumpkin (seasonal)

Cream Cheese

Marshmallow

Lavender

Pistachio

$2.00 per Macaron/$22 per Dozen

Cookies

Who doesn't look a good cookie? They're perfect for meetings and gatherings of any kind. We offer cookie platters and boxes by special order year round that you can mix and match to fit your needs. For large cookie orders we ask for at minimum 48 hour notice while smaller orders can be made the same day.

Chocolate Chip

Peanut Butter

Snickerdoodle

Double Chocolate

Brookie

Fruity Pebble

Pumpkin (seasonal)

Lemon (seasonal)

Mint Chocolate Chip

Brown Butter Bourbon Pecan

Mocha Nut

$1.50 each/$15 per dozen/+$5 for platters

All of these cookies can be made into Overstuffed Cookies like the OG (Two chocolate chip cookies with our Vanilla Buttercream sandwhiched between them), Peanut Butter Overload, Mocha and more!

$2.50 each/$28 per dozen

Cake Balls

Our cake balls start with ... you guessed it, our cake! We mix our cakes with vanilla buttercream then hand roll each cake ball before dipping them in rich dark or white chocolate and finishing them off with colorful sprinkles. Cake Balls are perfect for parties and we ask that you place your order at least 48 hours in advance for large orders.

Red Velvet

Chocolate

Vanilla

Pumpkin (seasonal)

Lemon (seasonal)

$2 each/$22 per dozen

Pepperoni Rolls

Everyone loves a good pepperoni roll and we think ours are pretty spectacular. It all starts with our scratch made dough, pepperoni, mozzarella cheese and ends with garlic butter and parmesan cheese. Every Thursday and Friday we stock our case with these delicious rolls and they don't hang around long!

$6 each