top of page
Thanksgiving

We're taking Thanksgiving Pre Orders now till 11/21! All Thanksgiving items will be available for pick up 11/24-26. Please select your pickup date when ordering.



Cupcakes

Our Thanksgiving cupcakes are beautifully decorated and extra delicious! Please note that decor is based on availabilty and subject to change.




Red Velvet

This Southern Classic should be a staple for your holiday celebration!

$3.75

Holiday Cupcake Quantities

1/2 Dozen

$18.75

Dozen

$41.25


Pumpkin Cheesecake

Perfectly spiced Pumpkin cake, filled with our very own Cheesecake batter then baked to perfection and topped with tangy Cream Cheese Buttercream.

$3.75

Holiday Cupcake Quantities

1/2 Dozen

$18.75

Dozen

$41.25


Fall Funfettit

The same Funfetti you know and love got a Thanksgiving Glow Up!

$3.75

Holiday Cupcake Quantities

1/2 Dozen

$18.75

Dozen

$41.25


Chocolate Peanut Butter

Our absolutely perfect Chocolate Peanut Butter cupcake but with a fun and festive design perfect for the holiday!

$3.75

Holiday Cupcake Quantities

1/2 Dozen

$18.75

Dozen

$41.25


Cherry Almond

Our elegant "Wedding Cake" cupcake is getting an upgrade with cherry chunks baked in, topped with almond buttercream and a cherry on top!

$3.75

Holiday Cupcake Quantities

1/2 Dozen

$18.75

Dozen

$41.25


Apple Pie

Is anything more quintessentially fall than an Apple Pie cupcake? We certaintly don't think so!

$3.75

Holiday Cupcake Quantities

1/2 Dozen

$18.75

Dozen

$41.25


Chocolate Vanilla

Classic and delicious, our Chocolate Vanilla cupcakes are all dressed up and ready for Thanksgiving!

$3.75

Holiday Cupcake Quantities

1/2 Dozen

$18.75

Dozen

$41.25


Turtle

Chocolate cake filled with caramel and pecans topped with a cream caramel buttercream and more pecans!

$3.75



Turkey Dinner Cupcake Arrangement

This 6 Pack of cupcakes is decorated to look like all of your favorite Thanksgiving dishes such as: Turkey Leg, Pumpkin Pie, Corn, Sweet Potato Casserole, Stuffing, Mashed Potatoes and Corn! They even come in a cute little aluminum tray!

$30

Turkey Dinner Cupcake Arrangement



Pies

Every pie is made from start to finish in house!




Pumpkin

A classic Thanksgiving pie that is too delicious to pass up! Our perfectly spiced pumpkin pie filling and hand crafted pie shell is sure to wow your family!

$28

Cream Pie Topping

Whipped Cream

Toasted Meringue

$4


Pecan

Yummy pecans, gooey filling and a flaky pie crust make our Pecan Pie a hit with the family ever Thanksgiving!

$35



Apple

Our Apple Pie is better than other store bought pies because our apples are hand peeled and chopped, our crusts are made from scratch and we put our whole heart into each one!

$35

Fruit Pie Options

Crumb Topping

Double Crust

$4
Apple


Apple Berry

If you thought our Apple Pie was phenomenal, you won't be disappointed in our Apple Berry! Tart apples and mixed berries are the perfect combo!

$35

Fruit Pie Options

Crumb Topping

Double Crust

$4


Peanut Butter

This Best Seller is a must have at the Thanksgiving dinner table! Our Oreo crust is filled with creamy, whipped peanut butter filling and topped with homemade whipped cream, chocolate and peanut butter drizzle and of course, Reese Cups!

$28

Cream Pie Topping

Whipped Cream

Toasted Meringue

$4


Coconut Dream

All the deliciousness of our Coconut Cream Pie but instead of a traditional pie crust, this pie features a Graham Cracker Coconut Crust!

$28

Cream Pie Topping

Whipped Cream

Toasted Meringue

$4


Graham Cracker

There's just something about this pie. It's a classic. It's delicious. It's perfect for any occassion. Creamy Vanilla custard and Graham Cracker Crust ... what a combo!

$28

Cream Pie Topping

Whipped Cream

Toasted Meringue

$4



Cheesecakes

Perfect for a crowd, you won't be able to resist our Cheesecakes!




Pumpkin

Perfectly spiced and full of pumpkin flavor!

$48

Cheesecake Topping

Whipped Cream

No Whipped Cream



White Chocolate Pumpkin Swirl

Our Classic Pumpkin Cheesecake gets a little upgrade with a creamy White Chocolate Cheesecake Swirl.

$48

Cheesecake Topping

Whipped Cream

No Whipped Cream



Classic New York

It's a classic for a reason!

$48

Cheesecake Topping

Whipped Cream

No Whipped Cream



Chocolate Lovers

For the real sweet lover in your life! This decadent cheesecake is ALL chocolate from the crust to the topping so grab a glass of milk and put your fat pants on- you can't resist digging into this one!

$48

Cheesecake Topping

Whipped Cream

No Whipped Cream



Chocolate Peppermint

A silky blend of rich dark chocolate and cool peppermint folded into a creamy cheesecake atop a crisp chocolate cookie crust. Finished with a glossy chocolate ganache and crushed peppermint for a festive crunch. Indulgent, refreshing, and perfect for the season.

$52

Cheesecake Topping

Whipped Cream

No Whipped Cream



White Chocolate Cranberry

We use our very own cranberry sauce to make this beautiful and decadent cheesecake extra special! The sweetness of the white chocolate and tartness of the cranberries is the perfect combo!

$52

Cheesecake Topping

Whipped Cream

No Whipped Cream




Sugar Cookies



Assorted Fall Shaped Sugar Cookies

Great for kids and adults alike after the best Thanksgiving dinner ever (or before!). Shapes include: pumpkins, leaves, etc.

1/2 Dozen

$21


Dozen

$42



Dinner Dipper Sugar Cookies

The cutest way to distract kids while you're busy with clean up. They can choose to dip their cookies in the "mashed potatoes" and "veggies" or decorate the cookies. This set includes: - 6 Undecorated Turkey Leg Shaped Sugar Cookies - Buttercream "Mashed Potatoes" - Candy "Peas and Carrots"

$18

Dinner Dipper Sugar Cookies



Brunch

Want a delicious breakfast but don't want to cook. Brunch Box!




Brunch Box

Choose from a selection of brunch goodies like Quiche, Scones, Muffins and more to create the perfect breakfast for the holidays! When making your selections, please note that Scones, Muffins and Croissants come in orders of 4 per flavor.

$32

Thanksgiving Scones

Cinnamon Chip

$15

White Chocolate Pumpkin

$15


Cherry Almond Coffee Cake

The perfect carefree breakfast on a busy day! Just sit it out and let everyone dig in! It's pairs with coffee

$30.00

Cherry Almond Coffee Cake



Giving Trays

Great for gifting! These trays feature: Pie Bites, Cake Balls and French Macarons




Mini Giving Tray

The Mini Giving Tray includes 1 Dozen total pieces. - 4 French Macarons - 4 Pie Bites - 4 Cake Balls

$32



Large Giving Tray

The Large Giving Tray includes 3 Dozen total pieces. - 1 Dozen French Macarons - 1 Dozen Pie Bites -1 Dozen Cake Balls

$95




Rolls



Pumpkin Roll

Every holiday table should have a homemade Pumpkin Roll on it!

Classic

$22


Add Pecans

$25



Yeast Rolls

Bread is hard. Let us make the most delicious, buttery Yeast Rolls you've ever had. All you have to do is reheat them. Each order comes with 1 Dozen Rolls.

$12

Yeast Rolls



Cakes

Perfect for taking to family dinner or keeping all to yourself!




Happy Thanksgiving Tray Cake

This gorgeous cake comes in a convienant aluminium tray (with lid) making it the perfect dessert for taking to family dinner. Serves 6-9. **No additions or changes can be made to the cake's design or flavor options.

Chocolate

$35


Fall Funfetti

$35


Pumpkin

$35

Happy Thanksgiving Tray Cake


Thankful Tray Cake

This gorgeous cake comes in a convienant aluminium tray (with lid) making it the perfect dessert for taking to family dinner. Serves 6-9. **No additions or changes can be made to the cake's design or flavor options.

Fall Funfetti

$35


Pumpkin

$35


Chocolate

$35

Thankful Tray Cake

Sugar Pie Bakery is on a mission to redefine what it means to celebrate with baked from scratch and hand decorated desserts made especially for you! 

Come see us at 94 RHL Boulevard, South Charleston WV 25309

Help & Info

Give us a call at 304-205-7753

Follow us:

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
Send us an email at 
info@sugarpiebakerywv.com
bottom of page