top of page

Christmas

Now taking Christmas Pre orders till 12/18! Christmas orders will be available for pick up 12/23 & 12/24.

Cupcakes

Sugar Plum

Our classic Almond cake but with a little holiday spice and a sweet raspberry filling. Decorated with snow flakes, sprinkles and glitter, the Sugar Plum is too cute to resist!

**Decor is subject to changes based on availability.

$4.25

Hot Cocoa

A quintessential Christmas flavor that's too hard to pass up! Our Chocolate cupcakes get filled with marshmallow, topped with real Hot cocoa buttercream + mini marshmallows and ganache!

**Decor subject to change based on availability

$4.25

Chocolate Peppermint Fudge

If you're a Peppermint Mocha fan, this is your cupcake! It's full of chocolate and peppermint flavor that goes perfect with the season. We were inspired by christmas lights when decorating this one with rainbow sugar and a giant gum ball on top!

**Decor subject to change based on availability

$4.25

Christmas Tree Cake

We turned everyone's favorite Christmas snack cake into one delicious cupcake and decorated it to match!

**Decor is subject to change based on availability

$4.25

Gingerbread

We LOVE Gingerbread anything in this bakery and we believe this cupcake is too cute to resist with it's little gingerbread man topper and cute mini chocolate bar!

**Decor subject to change based on availability

$4.25

Chocolate Vanilla

This cupcake's flavor profile might seem basic but it's a classic for a reason. We decorate it with the cutest Christmas tree on top too so it's perfect for the holidays.

**Decor subject to change based on availability

$4.25

Red Velvet Cheesecake

Just when you thought Red Velvet couldn't get any better, we've added a delicious Cheesecake filling! And to make it extra festive, we've decorated this cupcake to look like a Christmas Wreath!

**Decor subject to change based on availability

$4.25

Chocolate Peanut Butter

We've given our amazing Chocolate Peanut Butter cupcake a Christmas makeover and turned into the classic Christmas Pudding with fondant decor.

**Decor subject to change based on availability

$4.25

Cookies

Christmas Cookie Party Tray

This tray of delicious Christmas cookies is perfect for gifting or taking to all those Christmas parties.

Each tray comes with:
- Santa's Favorite (Chocolate Chip/ M&M)
- Hot Cocoa
- Sprinkle Sugar
- Gingerbread

1 Dozen

$28

​

3 Dozen

$80

​

Gingerbread Cookies

Gingerbread cookies and Christmas go together like ... cookies and Christmas haha. You get 1 dozen of these thick and chewy freshly baked cookies in each order.

$33

Decorate Your Own Cookie Kit

Kids will love our Decorate Your Own Cookie Kits because it's a delicious and fun activity. You'll love our Decorate Your Own Cookie Kits because you don't have to remember to bake cookies for Santa.

The Mini Kit Includes:
- 6 Undecorated Sugar Cookies
- 1 Container of Sprinkles
-2 Buttercreams

The Large Kit Includes:
- 12 Undecorated Sugar Cookies
- 3 Containers of Sprinkles
- 4 Buttercreams

Cookie Shapes, Sprinkles and Buttercream colors are subject to change based on availability but will all be Christmas themed.

Mini Kit

$18

​

Large Kit

$40

​

Cheesecakes

Salted Caramel

We use our very own caramel to make this Salted Caramel Cheesecake extra special!

$48

Christmas Tree Cake

Yall ... this is THE Cheesecake for Christmas! It's loaded with those little cakes we all know and love then decorated to match!

$70

Hot Cocoa

This Cheesecake is bursting with chocolately, marshmallowy deliciousness!

$52

White Chocolate Gingerbread Swirl

If you love the spice and rich molassass flavor of Gingerbread and creamy, rich White Chocolate ... just imagine how good the two flavors would taste combined!

$52

Classic New York

It's a classic for a reason!

$48

Red Velvet

Not only is this Cheesecake the perfect color for Christmas, it's just the perfect flavor for the holidays.

$48

Peanut Butter

One of our best sellers at every holiday, this Peanut Butter Cheesecake features a Chocolate Crust and so much peanut butter flavor you'll want to go back for seconds.

$48

Pies

Pumpkin Cream

Why settle for a regular ol Pumpkin Pie when you can have THIS pie that has a swirl of creamy cheesecake!

$28

Chocolate Pecan

We put a little spin on the classic Pecan Pie by adding a sprinkle of rich chocolate to the ooey gooey filling.

$32

Winter Berry

What is a Winter Berry? It's the delicious combination of spiced Apples and tart Cranberries!

$35

Apple

Our Apple Pie is better than other store bought pies because our apples are hand peeled and chopped, our crusts are made from scratch and we put our whole heart into each one!

$35

German Chocolate

Oh you thought German Chocolate was only for cakes? Think again! This pie consists of a Chocolate crust, creamy Chocolate filling and is topped with a delicious cookied coconut pecan topping!

$35

Peanut Butter Mousse

Rich chocolate crust, creamy whipped Peanut Butter filling and house made Whipped Cream make up the perfection that is our Peanut Butter Mousse Pie.

$28

Graham Cracker

There's just something about this pie. It's a classic. It's delicious. It's perfect for any occassion. Creamy Vanilla custard and Graham Cracker Crust ... what a combo!

$28

Cherry

This classic is tart, sweet and oh so delicious!

$35

Rolls

Yule Log

This French classic features a rich chocolate cake, cream filling and fudgey chocolate frosting.

$40

Pumpkin Roll

Every holiday table should have a homemade Pumpkin Roll on it!

Classic

$22

​

Add Pecans

$25

​

Yeast Rolls

Bread is hard. Let us make the most delicious, buttery Yeast Rolls you've ever had. All you have to do is reheat them. Each order comes with 1 Dozen Rolls.

$12

Brunch

Christmas Morning Brunch

There's no need to cook an big Christmas morning breakfast after the chaos of stockings and presents when you order one of our Brunch Boxes.

When making your selections, please note that Scones, Muffins and Croissants come in orders of 4 per flavor.

$35

Cheer Trays

Cheer Tray

Perfect for gifting or taking to all of those Christmas parties, you can't go wrong with a Cheer Tray (it's in the name)!

Each Tray Includes:
- New York Cheesecake Bites
- Gingerbread Cookies
- French Macarons
- Cake Balls

Flavors, Colors of French Macarons and Cake Balls are subject to change based on availabilty but will be Christmas themed.

1 1/2 Dozen

$50

​

3 Dozen

$145

​

Cakes

Merry Little Christmas

Featuring a cute pink and green color scheme, fondant accents and all the Christmas Cheer, this was our most popular design last year so we had to bring it back!

**There can be no changes or additions made to the Christmas Cakes.

Chocolate

$80

​

Christmas Funfetti

$80

​

Gluten Free Chocolate

$95

​

Gluten Free Christmas Funfetti

$95

​

Vintage Christmas

This Heart Shaped cutie is bringing all the vintage Christmas vibes to your dessert table with a classic red and green color palette and beautiful vintage piping.

**No changes or additions can be made to the Christmas Cakes

Chocolate

$80

​

Christmas Funfetti

$80

​

Gluten Free Chocolate

$95

​

Gluten Free Christmas Funfetti

$95

​

Classic Christmas

Quintessentially Christmas is the best way to describe this design!

**No changes or additions can be made to the Christmas Cakes

Chocolate

$80

​

Christmas Funfetti

$80

​

Gluten Free Chocolate

$95

​

Gluten Free Christmas Funfetti

$95

​

Sugar Pie Bakery is on a mission to redefine what it means to celebrate with baked from scratch and hand decorated desserts made especially for you! 

Come see us at 94 RHL Boulevard, South Charleston WV 25309

Help & Info

Give us a call at 304-205-7753

Follow us:

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
Send us an email at 
info@sugarpiebakerywv.com
bottom of page