top of page

Easter

Now taking pre orders for Easter til Tue 4/15! Orders will be available for pick up Fri. 4/18 and Sat. 4/19

Easter Cupcakes

Carrot Cake Cheesecake

Loaded with sweet carrots and cinnamon then filled with cheesecake filling, this cupcake is the Easter Bunny's favorite dessert! Also, how can you resist a little buttercream carrot on top?

$3.75

Chocolate Peanut Butter

We top our rich Chocolate cake with creamy Peanut Butter buttercream! It's no wonder it's a best seller! Add on a Reese egg and it's perfection.

$3.75

Chocolate Vanilla

This classic flavor combo of rich chocolate cake and sweet vanilla buttercream can't be beat! But when we make the buttercream the cutest pastel rainbow and add easter sprinkles, it gets even better!

$3.75

Almond Raspberry

When you add our Almond cake with raspberry preserves and sweet pink raspberry buttercream, you've got an Easter classic in your hands.

$3.75

Cadbury Cream

Either you LOVE Cadbury eggs or you're wrong. This chocolate cupcake is filled with our version of Cadbury cream then topped with a Cadbury egg!

$3.75

Funetti

Our Funfetti cake gets an Easter glow up with pastel rainbow buttercream and festive sprinkles!

$3.75

Lemon Blueberry

Tart lemon cake with fresh blueberries baked in is topped with lemon buttercream and decorated with a buttercream nest and malt egg candy.

$3.75

Red Velvet

Our best selling cupcake gets decorated for Easter with a cute little fondant topper!

$3.75

Easter Pies

Lemon Cream

This Lemon Pie is creamy, tart and piled into a buttery Graham Cracker crust.

$28

Peanut Butter

Our best selling cream pie of the year! It's chocolatey, peanut buttery and utterly irresistable!

$28

Graham Cracker

A Classic pie that you shouldn't sleep on! It features a delicious vanilla custard style filling, a buttery graham cracker crust and your choice of fresh whipped cream or merigne topping.

$28

Blueberry Peach

This pie is what spring tastes like! Full of sweet peaches and blueberries, it's the perfect Easter Pie.

$32

Strawberry

Similar to that restaurant we all know and love, our Strawberry Pie will be a hit at your Easter dinner.

$28

Coconut Cream

This old school pie is chock full of coconut flavor and perfect for after a massive Thanksgiving feast!

$28

Easter Cheesecakes

Classic New York

It's a classic for a reason!

$48

Lemon Blueberry

Tart lemon and blueberry is the best Easter combo!

$48

Peanut Butter

One of our best sellers at every holiday, this Peanut Butter Cheesecake features a Chocolate Crust and so much peanut butter flavor you'll want to go back for seconds.

$48

Carrot Cake

This is the Easter Bunny's favorite Cheesecake! It's full of carrots and bursting with spice!

$52

Marshmallow Peep

Peeps people will love this colorful Cheesecake bursting with sweet marshmallow flavor.

$52

Cadbury Cream

If you're a Cadbury Egg fan, this is your dessert! It's chocolatey and has that Cadbury cream flavor you're looking for.

$52

KETO New York

If any of your guests are watching their sugar or gluten intake, this Cheesecake is for them!

$56

Easter Brunch Box

Brunch Box

Let us make a gourmet breakfast to kick of your Easter celebration!

**Scones, Muffins, Danish and Croissants come with 4 per flavor/ per order.
Please note that Scones, Muffins and Croissants come in orders of 4 per flavor.

$32

Easter Cookies

Decorate Your Own Cookie Kit

Decorating your own Easter Cookies is much more delicious than decorating eggs so grab a Decorate Your Own Cookie Kit for the kids this Easter. We have two different sizes to fit your family.

Mini Kit:
- 6 Undecorated Sugar Cookies
- 2 Bags of Buttercream
- 1 container of Sprinkles

Large Kit:
- 12 Undecorated Sugar Cookies
- 3 bags of Buttercream
- 2 Sprinkles

**Cookie shapes/ buttercream colors/ sprinkles may vary but will be on theme

Mini Kit

$18

​

Large Kit

$40

​

Decorated Sugar Cookies

These cute little Sugar Cookies are perfect for Easter baskets or munching on while cooking Easter dinner!

**Shapes/ Colors/ Decor may vary but will be on theme

1/2 Dozen

$25

​

1 Dozen

$48

​

Easter Cakes & Rolls

Carrot Cake Roll

This sweet little cake roll is perfectly spiced, bursting with carrots and filled with tangy cream cheese filling.

$22

Yeast Rolls

Bread is hard. Let us bake the rolls and all you'll need to do is reheat! Each order comes with 1 Dozen Rolls

$12

Easter Cookie Cake

Celebrate with a Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake decorated in pretty pastels for Easter!

**Decor/ sayings will vary but be on theme

$25

Sugar Pie Bakery is on a mission to redefine what it means to celebrate with baked from scratch and hand decorated desserts made especially for you! 

Come see us at 94 RHL Boulevard, South Charleston WV 25309

Help & Info

Give us a call at 304-205-7753

Follow us:

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
Send us an email at 
info@sugarpiebakerywv.com
bottom of page